The Fractured Landscape of Early Song Dynasty

When Zhao Kuangyin, later known as Emperor Taizu of Song, seized power in 960, he inherited a fragmented empire. The newly established Song Dynasty controlled only the Yellow and Huai River basins—roughly half of what we now consider “China.” To the south lay rival states like Southern Tang, Wuyue, and Later Shu; to the north, the resilient Northern Han and the formidable Khitan-led Liao Dynasty held sway. This geopolitical puzzle mirrored the late Zhou Dynasty’s struggles, where Emperor Shizong had begun unification before his untimely death.

The critical question haunted Taizu: Should he strike south or north first?

The Ghost of Zhou Shizong’s Unfinished Campaign

Emperor Shizong of Zhou had initially followed strategist Wang Pu’s “south-first” blueprint but pivoted northward after securing territories south of the Yangtze. His sudden death in 959 during a campaign against the Khitan left his vision unfulfilled. Taizu, who had fought under Shizong, now faced the same crossroads.

In the dynasty’s first eight months, Taizu privately consulted Zhang Yongde, a former Zhou royal son-in-law. Zhang warned that Northern Han’s forces—though small—were battle-hardened and backed by Khitan cavalry. His proposal? “Harass their farms annually and sabotage Khitan alliances.” Taizu’s terse reply—”善” (Good)—hinted at lingering doubts.

The Snow Night Summit: A Fateful Decision

On a blizzard-swept night in 961, Taizu arrived unannounced at chancellor Zhao Pu’s home. Huddled around a fire with his brother Zhao Guangyi (the future Emperor Taizong), the emperor voiced his torment: “Beyond my bed lies land ruled by others.”

When Taizu proposed attacking Northern Han first, Zhao Pu fell silent before delivering a geopolitical masterstroke:
– Northern Han acted as a buffer against Khitan and Tangut tribes. Conquering it would expose Song to direct northern threats.
– Wealthy southern states like Later Shu and Southern Tang were richer but militarily weaker—ideal targets to fund future campaigns.

Taizu’s laughter—”I thought the same! I merely tested you”—masked a pivotal shift. The “Snow Night Strategy” was born: subdue the south, isolate the north.

Why Not the Khitan? The Unspoken Calculus

Modern critics like historian Qian Mu argue Taizu erred by not confronting the Khitan immediately. Yet evidence suggests his “northern” target was always Northern Han, not the Liao Dynasty’s heartland:
1. No records show Taizu planning to reclaim the Sixteen Prefectures (lost since 937).
2. His post-summit roadmap listed “Shu, Lingnan, Jiangnan, Hedong”—omitting Khitan territories.
3. When officer Wang Ming proposed invading Liao in 963, Taizu rewarded him but took no action.

Instead, Taizu devised a two-phase solution:
1. Military conquest of southern regimes to consolidate resources.
2. A peaceful buyback of the Sixteen Prefectures using a dedicated treasury (Fengzhuang Ku).

Legacy: Strategic Patience or Missed Opportunity?

The strategy’s merits were proven when:
– Southern conquests (963–978) filled Song coffers with Sichuan’s silk and Jiangnan’s rice.
– Northern failures: Taizu’s successor Taizong’s disastrous 979 and 986 invasions of Liao exposed the Khitan’s enduring might.

Yet critics like Southern Song poet Lu You lamented that exhausting troops on southern campaigns left Song too weak to later reclaim the north. The debate endures: was Taizu’s caution pragmatic or a historic blunder?

The Modern Lens: Geopolitics Over Glory

Taizu’s choice reflects timeless statecraft principles:
– Resource prioritization: Weak regimes with wealth (like Later Shu) were “low-hanging fruit.”
– Buffer states: Northern Han’s survival temporarily shielded Song from Khitan cavalry.
– Diplomatic creativity: The buyback plan—though never executed—showed non-military solutions for territorial disputes.

In an era of fragmented power, Taizu’s methodical approach built an economic powerhouse that sustained Song culture’s golden age—even if the northern frontier remained unresolved. The snow night’s embers thus kindled not just conquest, but a model of calculated empire-building.

—
Word count: 1,580